• عربي
  • Fr
  • Es
No Result
View All Result
European Eye on Radicalization
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
      • Editorial board and staff
      • Contributors
    • Vision
  • Analysis
  • Opinion Pieces
    • EER Editorials
    • Contributors’ Opinions
  • Reports
  • Reading Radicalization
  • Events
    • EER Events
    • Events EER attends
  • Interviews
  • Videos
  • Contact
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
      • Editorial board and staff
      • Contributors
    • Vision
  • Analysis
  • Opinion Pieces
    • EER Editorials
    • Contributors’ Opinions
  • Reports
  • Reading Radicalization
  • Events
    • EER Events
    • Events EER attends
  • Interviews
  • Videos
  • Contact
No Result
View All Result
European Eye on Radicalization
No Result
View All Result
Home Reading Radicalization

Book Review: ‘Jihadi Politics. The Global Jihad Civil War 2014-2019’

Tore Hamming; 2022; Hurst Publishers; 440 Pages

3 January 2023
in Reading Radicalization
Book Review: ‘Jihadi Politics. The Global Jihad Civil War 2014-2019’
1,249
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

European Eye on Radicalization

In November, Dr. Tore Hamming released Jihadi Politics. The Global Jihad Civil War 2014-2019, which builds on his PhD dissertation, and is likely the most comprehensive book on jihadism written in the last few year.

Dr. Hamming is Director of Refslund Analytics, and a non-resident fellow at the International Center for the Study of Radicalization, King’s College London. He has conducted fieldwork in Jordan, Iraq, Egypt, Morocco, Nigeria and Somalia, and has written for Le Monde, Al Jazeera, and The Guardian, among others.

Traditionally, both experts and the general public know little about what goes on inside jihadist movements, as they are made of secretive and clandestine actors. The book largely fills this gap by going beyond the traditional narratives and focusing on the internal dynamics of the jihadist movement with the aim of explaining conflict among groups and individuals. In the author’s words, much is about al-Qaeda and the Islamic State but, throughout the story, other groups are involved.

Invaluable Resource

Hamming’s work is an invaluable resource thanks to its double perspective that allows readers to get a better understanding of the broad drivers of conflict and the importance of theology and ideology, while at the same time meticulously describing the role and actions of many individuals who were central in either exacerbating or mitigating internal conflict.

The most important insight relates to the status of jihadists, which, throughout history, has often gone way beyond that of religious extremists. The book provides a nuanced interpretation of jihadists as political actors and helps explain the rationale driving their violence and forming their identity. As such, it goes against the narrative of viewing jihadists as exclusively religious extremists.

Why do jihadists engage in, and even prioritize, conflicts with other jihadists with whom they often share a history, grand strategy, and ideology? They largely seek the same ultimate objective but disagree about the methods to reach that objective and other minor theological issues. For example, these include the criteria for establishing an Islamic political entity and the process of declaring someone an unbeliever. Existing explanations for intra-jihadist conflict tend to argue that extremist ideology is at fault, causing jihadists to turn against one another.

Conventional Politics Rationale

Hamming’s perspective, however, is that extremism alone is insufficient to explain jihadist fratricide fights. Instead, intra-jihadist conflict is better explained through a conventional power politics rationale. Groups fight because they want to dominate and because they strive for some degree of hegemony. Certain groups view themselves as representing the one and only religiopolitical authority on either a local, regional, or global scale, whereas others view themselves as one among equals.

The Islamic State’s declaration of a caliphate, for example, represents a claim to be the only legitimate Islamic authority, whereas al-Qaeda generally views itself as one fighting group — albeit the preferable option — among many. These diverging perceptions inform not only how groups view themselves but also how they engage with other groups, whether through cooperation or conflict. Unsurprisingly, those seeking hegemony are prone to challenge rival jihadists that they view as competitors.

A History of Intra-Jihadist Conflict

Hamming’s work should be regarded as a history of intra-jihadi conflict seen through the jihadis’ own lenses.  Primarily dealing with the conflict between al-Qaeda, the Islamic State, and related jihadist groups, it covers the intra-group period leading up to the split between al-Qaeda and its Iraqi affiliate (1999-2013), the split itself (2014) and the ensuing period of inter-group contestation and fighting (2014-2019).

The research question moving the author’s investigation was why do jihadists fight with each other? Indeed, this seems like a paradox based on three assumptions. First, on an ideological level, jihadists share more than what divides them. Second, given that they are usually facing a superior enemy, it would seem reasonable to think that jihadists would gain more from cooperation than from infighting. Third, they are extremely isolated political actors with few other potentially cooperative partners.

The negative consequences of fighting each other appear obvious, and this is what makes the author’s research question strikingly compelling. Ultimately, political rifts and fratricide within the jihadist movement weaken these extremist groups. The question remains whether Western policymakers and military leaders are willing to further exploit these divisions to their advantage.

As far as the structure is concerned, the book is divided into six parts comprising 13 chapters, with an Introduction, an Epilogue, and a few interesting appendixes.

  • Part One, The Politics of Sunni Jihadism, presents the conceptual framework and discusses the notion of conflict within the Sunni jihadi movement.
  • Part Two, Setting the Stage, introduces the historical background for the contemporary conflict.
  • Part Three, Intensification of Conflict, deals with the intensification of the internal clash.
  • Part Four, Movement Fragmentation, Polarization and Internationalization, discusses the next phases of the conflict, characterized by momentous change on the jihadist political level.
  • Part Five, Between Purity and Pragmatism, analyzes the many ways in which the radicalization of the conflict took place. Finally, Part Six, Internalizing Fitna, looks at how intra-jihadist conflict became internalized within the respective groups in 2016-2019 as pressure from the inside to reform ultimately led to renewed fragmentation and an escalation of hostilities.

Empirically Rich

As Michael A.K.G. Innes, author of Streets Without Joy, appropriately explains, books on ISIS that have emerged over the last few years make note of the fitna, but none explore it in this much depth. Therefore, Dr. Hamming’s work can be regarded as an empirically rich account from a world-leading expert that will undoubtedly take its place as a key reference for anyone seeking to make sense of al-Qaeda and its legacies.

Based on the author’s tremendous knowledge of jihadism and the Middle East, years of digital anthropology, hundreds of primary documents, and interviews with jihadists, Jihadi Politics, The Global Jihad Civil War 2014-2019 offers an unprecedented glimpse into what likely is the most complex phase in history of jihadism, while, at the same time, providing an interesting and thought-provoking perspective on its future evolution and trajectories.

Related Posts

Al-Tawsmat: A Short Manuscript That Established A Fatal Ideology
Reading Radicalization

Al-Tawsmat: A Short Manuscript That Established A Fatal Ideology

14 November 2022
The Continuing Threat of Extremist Islam in Southeast Asia
Reading Radicalization

The Continuing Threat of Extremist Islam in Southeast Asia

10 November 2022
Book Review: ‘Institutionalizing Violence: Strategies of Jihad in Egypt’
Reading Radicalization

Book Review: ‘Institutionalizing Violence: Strategies of Jihad in Egypt’

1 November 2022
Book Review: ‘The Secret Apparatus. The Muslim Brotherhood’s Industry of Death’
Reading Radicalization

Book Review: ‘The Secret Apparatus. The Muslim Brotherhood’s Industry of Death’

17 October 2022
Book Review: “Enemies, Near and Far”
Reading Radicalization

Book Review: “Enemies, Near and Far”

10 October 2022
The Risk of Whitewashing the Muslim Brotherhood
Reading Radicalization

The Risk of Whitewashing the Muslim Brotherhood

20 September 2022

Latest from Twitter

Popular

The Challenges of Combatting Extremist Financing in Germany

The Challenges of Combatting Extremist Financing in Germany

6 January 2023
The Myth of the Remote-Controlled Car Bomb

The Myth of the Remote-Controlled Car Bomb

16 September 2019

Taliban: Structure, Strategy, Agenda, and the International Terrorism Threat

7 October 2022
How a Swedish Agency Stopped Funding the Muslim Brotherhood

How a Swedish Agency Stopped Funding the Muslim Brotherhood

5 September 2022
Becoming Ansar Allah: How the Islamic Revolution Conquered Yemen

Becoming Ansar Allah: How the Islamic Revolution Conquered Yemen

24 March 2021
The Role of Online Communities in the Expansion of Far-Right Extremism

The Role of Online Communities in the Expansion of Far-Right Extremism

3 November 2022

© 2018 EER - Copyright © European Eye on Radicalization.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Who We Are
      • Editorial board and staff
      • Contributors
    • Vision
  • Analysis
  • Opinion Pieces
    • EER Editorials
    • Contributors’ Opinions
  • Reports
  • Reading Radicalization
  • Events
    • EER Events
    • Events EER attends
  • Interviews
  • Videos
  • Contact
  • عربي
  • Fr
  • Es

© 2018 EER - Copyright © European Eye on Radicalization.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.